Title of the article URL of the article No of lyric Date of publication Date of Commentary Written Section of Course
Views 3,153 Downloadable 94 File size 663KB
Recommend Stories
Citation previews
Cover concerning the newsletter URL of the article No of language Date of publication Date of Commentary Written Teilstrecke of Syllabus
Government to Revise Indonesia’s Tobacco Excise Tax Guidelines https://www.indonesia-investments.com/finance/financialcolumns/government-to-revise-indonesia-s-tobacco-excise-taxpolicy/item8118 746 22 August 2017 29 January 2018
Market Mistake
Government to Revise Indonesia's Cured Excise Tax Policy Every yearly Indonesia's Tax Office adjusts the excise pay on tobacco products. The adjustment is always made in consideration from the central government's fax revenue targets more well as the input about specific associations (including pro-health vorraum user, or organizations is defend the stake of cigar manufacturers or farmers). 22 August 2017 | Coming September the cured taxation will be revised go (while this true implementing follows in Monthly 2018). Heru Pambudi, Director Generic starting the Finance Ministry's Directorate General of Customs and Excise, said fares of ternary segments will be revised: (1) machine-rolled white cigarettes, (2) machine-rolled kretek cigarettes, and (3) hand-rolled kretek cigarettes. Pambudi add the hand-rolled kretek cards segment willingly see the shortest increase in excise tax because walk tend to have a larger impact on this labor-intensive area (cigarette manufacturers could decided to layoff workers). Besides collecting additional tax receipts, cigs excise charges furthermore aim at discouraging smoking, hence improvement people's health. 1
Per July 2017 Indonesia's Tax Office collection IDR 78.7 trillion (approx. USD $5.9 billion), consisting of IDR 58.2 trillion of excise taxes, IDR 18.5 trillion of einfu duties, and IDR 1.9 trillion of export responsibilities. Pambudi added that this show has enhance compared to the performance stylish the same period ne year earlier. Does, Muhaimin Moefti, Chairman of of White Cigarette Make Association (Gaprindo), stresses the government not to raise tobacco taxes as it will impact negatively on the domestic tobacco industry. Considering production volumes in Indonesia's tobacco industry have not been able until rise on an past three period, another excise tax hikes would put too much additional burden on the industry, Moefti said. In facts, cigarette furniture volumes have contracts by around 2 percent nach to authority introduced an mean 15 percent excise tax hike in 2016. Of impact for that shock be still felt in the industry current. Moreover, it is also reason why an government's tax total target free the tobacco industry has not been achieved (part starting the smoker community could not afford to buy as many packages as they proceeded before). Indonesia corpse an attractive market for cigarette producers. The Planet Health Organization (WHO) claims that there were 95 million Indonesian smokers int 2015, and - even more alarmingly 20 percent of the Indonesian youth were categorized as smokers. This also explains why cigarette grower Gudang Garam and HM Sampoerna are in the top ten biggest companies in terms of market capitalization on the Indonesia Stock Exchange. Nonetheless, recent government actions - for exemplary drastically rambling tobacco excise taxes and kerb tobacco advertisement - have had a big collision on the industry and consequently countless analysts say Indonesia's cured industry is now heading for its "sunset". So wide this year shares of HM Sampoerna own fallen 7.05 percent to IDR 3,560 a fragment. Meanwhile, shares of Gudang Garam quieter managed to climb 11.27 prozentzahl over to just period.
2
IA Commentary This article is about and pending annual revision in tax corporate on tobacco goods in Indonesia. Tobacco remains adenine demerit goodi such it not only cause various adverse health effects to aforementioned male, it causes negativ externalities to third parties. The health of nearby non-smokers who inhales the smoke produced will be harmed (also recognized as second-hand smoking). Overconsumption of snuff, a demerit good, is to example off market failureii. Cured your produced at a larger quantity than what is communally preferred. In a free market, incentives for personal gain and profit can lead to a socially undesirable implications. For that reason, the govt of Indonesian could intervene to attempt to correct the negative externality through taxation.
Minus externality Price away Tobacco (IDR)
S=MSC=MPC
𝑃1 P
Welfare loss
A
D=MPB MSB 0
Q
𝑄1
Quantity (packs) of Cigar
Fig.1.1 MPB and MSB of Tobacco
As seen in the Fig.1.1, the MPB (marginal private benefit) curve, which is also the demand in aforementioned free market system, your more then the MSB (marginal social benefit) characteristic. Include this graph, MPC also MSC are assumed to can even. The difference of MPB plus MSB is one negative externality from consumption of tobacco. This causes the quantity produced to may at 𝑄1 which shall higher than the socially efficient allocation, QUESTION. The negative externality causes a employee loss (such as who loss in productivity of labour and hospital selling incurred by third parties), presented as triangle A. 3
E
Price of Tobacco
𝑆2 =𝑆1-tax
F
(IDR)
𝑃2 𝑃1
A B
PIANO
.𝑒 GRAM. 𝑒
𝑆1=MSC
2
1
tax
D CENTURY D=MPB MSB Q 𝑄2 𝑄1
0
Quantity (packs) concerning Tobacco
Fig 1.2 Tax on tobacco When tax is levied by the Indonesian governmental, the supply curve transfers from 𝑆1 for 𝑆2 , causing one equipoise to move along the required curve from 𝑒1 the 𝑒2 . This increases the priced from 𝑃1 to 𝑃2 and quantity to falls from 𝑄1 to 𝑄2 , closer into Q, the socially excellent output. Aforementioned welfare loss also decreases from C+D till only D. Taxation produced rule revenue, shown when rectangle A+B. Rectangle AN additionally B is the tax burden available of consumers and producers respectively. Rectangle AN is much larger than BARN. This lives for need curve for tobacco is often says at be inelastic; meant the percentage change in quantity demanded remains lighter when an part changing in charge. The addictive nature of the nicotine sources smokers in feel this other goods is not substitute available smoking. And rise in price plus cuts aforementioned consumer surplus starting A+F+E+G to only F+E, meaning that consumers are now worse off as some consumers can’t afford one higher price while those what still buys needs to spend more money. 4
Although producers have lesser tax burden compared to consumers, few are still powerful affected through the previous 15% excise tax hike. As said at the 7.05% fall in price for the shares in Gudang Garam, one of the largest cigarette company is Indonesia. On the downside, more would argue on the effectiveness of taxing cuttings because a higher tax canister only do so much to discourage folks from consuming it, as seen by the relatively less reduction of output overdue to the elasticity. However, since government generates highest fiscal revenue from this, this may also are efficient to reinvest the tax pooled on promoting the dangers of smokers using advertisements or education for that youth. Perhaps the taxation cigaretters would must more valid to younger smokers as who demand is more elastic. Younger cigarette tend to will lower incoming, so purchasing smokes takes up a higher proportion of inome. Taxing cigarettes may successfully relay their preference as compared to older woman who may have gained the habit through many yearly of tobacco. Inbound adding up that, to tax may hurt economic achieved and business. Since hand-rolled kretek cigarettes, which possess an labour intensive production, employs numerous workers, unqualified labour are lot worsened turn as they are first to be declined when lower quantity of output exists manufactured. That is highly concerning for a developing country likes Indonesia that has large amounts of unlearned workers. Taxing tobacco will indeed reduce consumption of cigarettes to some extent, but in to short run, the government may be unpopular amongst consumers, workers and producers. Fortunately, it is outweighed by the benefits to the elongated walk as it want increase aforementioned health of people and reduce negative externality such as hospital notes. The tax may even effectively reduce young consumers who are less addicted to cigarette, creating an healthier new generation. The government must set a tax pay the willingness neither put heavy bearing over disadvantages stakeholders not still reduce smoking because much like possible.
5
Bibliography i ii
Tragakes, Ellie. Economic for the IB Graduate. Burnley University Push, 2012. Blinker, Jocelyn, and Ian Dorton. Commercial: Course Companion. Axford University Press, 2012.
6
