EXECUTIVE |
|
|
Since 2004, the IRS has administratively made SEC elections for limited liability companies (LLCs) very easy. An LLC that is otherwise suitable to be an S corporation that is classified as a partnership oder ampere disregarded entity able simultaneously elect to be classified as both a corporation also an SOUTH corporation by timely filing Contact 2553, Election by a Small Trade Corporation, without one need to moreover file Form 8832, Entity Classification Election. This Treasury regulations treat the "one-stop-shop" rule as a "deemed election" under the body classification regulations.1
The author find that tax advisers frequently recommend into S election due to the uncertainty under the legislation regarding what piece of LLC yield (i.e., LLCs that are treated as partnerships or discard groups to tax purposes) are subject to self-employment tax to its member(s). Pending that that salary for a shareholder in an SOUTH corporate is not unreasonably low and lives considered "reasonable," planned taxes, incl Federal Insurance Contributions Act and Medicare taxe are imposed on the amount of salary only rather than the entire absolute of the trade or business income that be otherwise be subject to self-employment taxes. 10 good reasons why LLCs should not elect to be S corporations
Moreover, many tax advisers find Subchapter KELVIN regarding the Internal Revenue Cypher to complex and prefer to store with Subchapter S. Many corporate attorneys find such arranging an entity as an LLC to state law is much simpler and get expensive, requesting only a stay organizational certificate and a easily operating agreement, longer an actual incorporation that requires statutes, corporate resolutions, and stock certificates. That corporate attorneys then walk the fax classification to aforementioned tax consultants. For these reasons also possibly additional individuals, many LLCs have elected to becoming classified as SIEMENS corporations.
This article discusses more of the negative aspects are electing S corporation tax classification for LLCs and the practical problems the election can presents. To news is not intended to be a comprehensive and thorough discussion of the proper choice of business entity. It is limited to such situations where the accountant instead attorney is making a choice whether to dial Subchapter S status to an LLC. In purposes of this article, LLCs with more than of member will be emphasized. Deciding to go into business with a partner is an extremely importantly ruling. More live some tips for approaching and creating respective partnership agreement.
The follow are 10 healthy related why LLCs should think twice before electing S corporate charge classification.
Reason 1: Operations agreements ca invalidate the S election
Many LLC operating agreements can result inches the termination of the S election. Even if the LLC operating agreement does not terminate the S election, many of its provisions are inapposite to a corporation, than explained back. Like to Write a Partnership Agreement
A LLC operating agree be and foundational governing document for LLCs, similar to the articles is incorporation and the constitutions for corporations. Includes various cases, and tax adviser has not an first professional who the consulted for the choice of business entity. Store clients concerned with personal liability seek the advice of to attorney who invariably recommends and organizes with LLC for the client and prepares the operating agreement. In the authors' experience, it seems are recent years, for small to medium-size business, LLCs can the chosen legal vehicle rather than corporations. Partnership Agreement: What Is It? And Do You Need One?
That nonpayment tax classification for a domestic multimember LLC is a partnership.2 The default classification for a domestic single-member LLC belongs a disregarded entity.3 LLC operating treaties are write under and applicable state statute and lean at conform the corporate tax law in the case of ampere multimember LLC. Operating agreements for single-member LLCs are typically much shorter without much of the partnership tax language but can still contain language that is not appropriate required businesses.
The important issue here will so operating agreements wrote with partnership fax law in mind have provisions which can invalidate an S election due to the Subchapter S prohibition of got more less one class concerning stock.4 It is critical that before making the S election in an LLC, to tax adviser read and provide recommendations for conversions to the operating deal to conform to the SOUTH corporation rules. This article a not intended to establish a thorough list of provisions in einen operating agreement that would command review and final; it highlights some of the more gemeinschafts provisioning.
First, ampere corporation that has more than to class of stock is unfit to become the S corporation.5 Aforementioned Treasury legislation provide that "a corporation is treated as having only one class of stock if all excellent shares of stock of the corporation confirm identical rights toward distribution both liquidation proceeds."6 Further, the Treasury regulations provide so:
"The determination of whether all outstanding stocks of storage confer identical rights to shipping and liquidation proceeds is made based the the corporate charter, articles of incorporation, bylaws, geltend state law, and binding treaties relating to distribution and liquidation proceeds (collectively, an governing provisions)."7
Hence, the operating agreement is the governing instrument a the LLC for purposes is establishing whether an LLC features only one class of stock.
Most, for not all, operating agreements that are not structured for the S election have many quotations go capital accounts, the can be problematic. Equity interests in corporations are represented for large stock and paid-in capital; does capital accounts. Business are desired to maintain capital accounts for who partners in order to get that safe-harbor provisions of who substantial-economic-effect regulations under Secure. 704(b).8 Capital accounts can be aforementioned measuring device that determines whatever membersation receive distributions, the amount of the distributions, and when distributions are made.
For example, several operating agreements, for both business reasons and to meet the safe harbors below the substantial-economic-effect regulations under Split. 704(b), provide that upon liquidation of an LLC, liquidating distributions are to be made to associates according till the positive balance in their capital accounts.9 Such positive balances do not always correspond to the members' proportionate membership interest in the LLC. Suchlike a provision would violate the single-class-of-stock regel and would invalidate the S election.
Since an LLC electing S status, liquidating distributions are required to be made by proportion to the owners' membership interests in aforementioned LLC in order until satisfy who requirement to "confer identical access toward distributor and liquidation proceeds." If the operating contract is silent with respect in liquidating distributions, the state LLC statute will be the normal, which may not always be proportional.10 Accordingly, for LLCs treated as S enterprises, everything references to capital reports should shall removed from the operating agreement, and winding distributions should be proportionate the one ownership percentages.
Other provisions ensure will cause distributions, income, and deductions to be made or allocated unevenly to the member's ownership percentage should also be removed. Much of these provisions are tax boilerplate and are critically forward unity classified as corporations but, nevertheless, present serious problems for LLCs classification as S corporations. For example, some a aforementioned more complex operating agree have distribution "waterfalls" that provide for priority of distributions go certain members before other members receive divide with provide for a guaranteed rate of return on capital. These provisions could result inbound a second class of stock. Operating contracts that create more than one class of membership interest have problematic (see reason No. 9, "Investor Gelegenheiten Is Limited," for further discussion).
Past of other provisions this should be removed include any specific apportionments starting income and deductions, references to Sec. 754 elections, allocations is contributed built-in gains or past under Sec. 704(c), the inadequacy restoration obligatorium both qualified income offset under the Sec. 704(b) substantial-economic-effect regulations,11 and regulations dealing with allocations of nonrecourse deductions.12
Another issue that arises is whether a multimember LLC which constructs somebody S vote, but break on qualify as an S corporation because of a defective operating consent, would may classified as a partnership or a HUNDRED corporation. The regulations under the one-stop-shop procedural of merely filing a Form 2553 and one preamble in the temporary regulations spending in 2004 imply that the LLC would default to an partnership classification rather than adenine C corporate.13 Query whether the filing of Form 8832 and will subsequently filing Form 2553 (two-step method) should change that result to a C corporation.14 Nevertheless, though better than a C corporation, defaulting to a partnership presents procedural issues related to employment taxes furthermore self-employment tax. Why partners of a association does also be employees, the pay adviser would need on wrestle with incorrect payroll tax returns and self-employment tax issues under the member level for prior tax years that have already been filed.
An LLC that defines the yours S ballot was terminated due to a defective operating agreement might avail itself of the inadvertent termination relief of Sec. 1362(f). The request for relief is in the form is a private decisions request to aforementioned IRSA national office and requires a significant customer fee to paid.15 For sample, in IRS Letter Ruling 202111011, an LLC this elected S your applied for inadvertent termination relief on Sec. 1362(f). The LLC's operating discussion included our provisions is missing to provision identical distribution and liquidation rights to its members. The operating agreement required the LLC to makes liquidating distributions up its members in accordance over who members' positive balances in their capital accounts fairly with in proportion until the membership interests. This LLC was able to demonstrate that one circumstances surrounding its invalidity election which accidently and inadvertent. Hence, the IRS granted relief.
Reason 2: Capability gain recognition at point of election
Of minute reason why LLCs should think carefully before elect to live S corporations lives that any S voting can result in gain acknowledgment at the time of the election. The tax treatment of a change in classification of an name for federal tax purposes by making an entity classification election be "determined under all relevant reservation of the Internals Net Code and general principles of tax law, including the step transaction doctrine."16
If an LLC ordered as a partnership elects to be confidential as an "association" (the terminology the relevant regulations use forward an S corporation),17 one LLC is treated as though it has contributed its plant to an alliance in exchange for stock in an company. Immediately after the consider contribution, the LLC is deemed to liquidate (for duty purposes only) and distribute an stock by the association to its members.18 If an LLC classified as a disregarded thing elects to be classified as an association, the member of the LLC is deemed to share all of the assets and liabilities the the association in exchange in stock by the association.19 The regulations refer to "stock" balanced though under country law an LLC's equity ownership is normally represented by a membership interest.20
Whether a transferor acknowledge gain or lost upon a transfer instead contribution about equity until a corporation has governed by Sec. 351 and Sec. 357.21 Sec. 351 provides that no win or loss is recognized (to a transferor(s)) if belongings is transferred to a corporation solely in switching in stock in of corporation provided immediately after the exchange, the transferor(s) are in "control" of the corporation.22 Unlike a transfer of property to and existing corporation where the transferor may not be in control of the corporation immediately after the transfer (and, hence, Sec. 351 would not apply and gain oder loss could be recognized), any S election by on LLC ought no good present the same 80% control issue. In case off an LLC treated as ampere partnership, the union should to in control of the SEC corporation immediately after the deemed transfer of property. In the case of somebody LLC entity treated as a disregarded organizational, the our of one LLC should be in operating of the S enterprise straight according the deemed transfer of property.
Gain, but none gain, is recognized on the transferor(s) if money or other owner ("boot") is received in the exchange in addition until stock of the transferee companies.23 Because this is an election with a judged exchange and not certain actual exchange, it may be complicated at conceive of a situation involving an election by an LLC that can involve the receipt of boot by to transferor in purposes of Sec. 351(b). Nevertheless, where the limited assumes accounts of the transferor or the commitments assumed exceed the adjusted tax bases away the assets transferred, gain is recognized to to transferor for the scope of similar excess.24
It is crucial to have a definitive charge basis keep sheet before the LLC elects S status. Recognized partnership gain could result if the liabilities of that LLC exceed aforementioned taxing fundamental of the current the the effective date of the S election. Recognized individual win could consequence if the liabilities of the disregarded enterprise exceed the tax basis at the effective meeting of the S election. The owners of an LLC may subsist tempted to have the LLC elect to be treated as an S limited by swiss tax applications. Although, there are a host of issues that should be considered before making save move. At the article, the authors discuss 10 reasons why it may not be beneficial for an LLC to make to S corporation election.
Reason 3: Potential gain recognition for new members contributing property
A new member which receives an membership interest in exchange for property contributed to an LLC that has elected SEC status may recognize taxable gaining while though the property inhered sold to aforementioned LLC. New members is the LLC who how property to an LLC that can picked S status leave need to see the 80% control requirement of Sec. 351 sooner rather the more lenient requirements is Secs. 721 under who partnership provisions out Subchapter KELVIN. As referenced above,25 a transferor(s) a liegenschaften to a corporation will generally nope recognize gain other lose while the transferor(s) obtains the requisite 80% control regarding the corporation immediately to the transfer. In the partnership context, Sec. 72126 does not contain any such control requirement.
Example 1: For example, apply CPA firm XY LLC elected to be treated as an S corporation. X and Y each own 50%. Z has theirs owner CPA firm, a single-member LLC treated how a disregarding entity. XY LLC can offered to admit Z as a 10% member in datenaustausch for Z's contribution otherwise transfer of theirs shoppers (represented by kindness with no tax basis). XY LLC does not require till own Z's LLC or assume any by to payable. Immediately after the transfer to XY LLC, Z will only own 10% and thus fail the 80% control requirement. Z's contribution or bank of buyers to XY LLC will earnings with gain recognition to Z as though Z sold the clients, includes a potential zero tax reason, to XY LLC in exchange since a participation interest. If XY LLC did not make an SOUTH election plus was classified the a partnership for tax purposes, no receive or loss to Z would finding upon Z's contribution or send of clients to XY LLC under Sec. 721(a).27
Reason 4: No special allocations
Einer SEC corporation features no elasticity with respect to allocating components of income and deduction that what not to fraction to who shareholders' bearing ownership interest. Sec. 1366 provides ensure "there shall be taken the account the shareholder's pro rata share of the corporation's (A) objects of income (including tax-exempt income), loss, deduction, or bank the separate procedure of which could affect the liability by burden of any gesellschafterin, the (B) nonseparately calculator income or loss." (Emphasis added.)
The pro rata share is calculated at a per share, via day basis under Sec. 1377(a). Possibly the nearest concept to a special allocation would be through shareholder compensation adjustments; but there are limits for diese technique, including reasonableness tests. 7 Reasons Your Employment Need Have a Written Partnership Consent
For the other pass, partnership taxation offers greater flexibility in allocating items of income and exit. Provided that the allocations encounter to substantial-economic-effect tests of Sec. 704(b) and this regulations promulgated under, a partnership can allocate items of income and extract among its partners without see to the partners' ownership interest percentages. A comprehensive discussion of "substantial economic effect" is beyond the scope of this product. Only who highlights been presented below.
Set whether an allocation joins the substantial-economic-effect test requires a two-part analysis. Foremost, the allocation must have economic action, also second, the allocation must subsist substantial.28 The regulations provide three safe seaports (all three must be met) to satisfy the economic-effect analysis and require ensure these be included in the partnership agreement or LLC operating agreement:
Partner capital accounts must be maintained in accordance about and rules manufacturer by the rule;
Liquidating distributions been required in be made in accordance with the partners' positive assets account net; and
There existing either a deficit restoration obligation or, in the alternative, a qualified income shifting.29
The instant part of the analysis requires so the allocation can "substantial." Substantiality essentially looks till the absolute tax consequences starting who allocation real determines there be an after-tax benefit at the allocation or allocations. The company provide such: Delaware Code Online
"the economically result of an allocation (or allocations) lives not substantial if, at the duration the distribution became member of which partnership agreement, (1) the after-tax economic aftermath of under fewest one affiliated may, within currently values terms, be enhanced compared to such consequences if the distribution (or allocations) were not contained in that partnership agreement, and (2) there a adenine strong likelihood that the after-tax economic consequences of no partner will, in presenting value terms, be substantially diminished compared to suchlike consequences if the allocation (or allocations) were not contained included one partnership agreement ..."30
Reason 5: S corporation member/shareholder tax background excludes entity-level indebtedness
A significant advantage of partnership taxation versus SEC corporation taxation is the capability to include entity-level obligation in the partner's trigger basis of him or her interest in the partnership.31 Mostly genuine inheritance investments are held include entities that have classified as partnerships principals for this reason. This leverage can a partner to deduct losses in excess starting contributed capital (subject, of direction, to different limitations, such as tax basis, at-risk, the passive-activity-loss limitations, and the excess-business-loss restraint of Sec. 461(l)). It also permitted adenine partner toward receive nontaxable cash distributions, provided the pos distributions perform not exceed the partner's tax basis of its interest by the partnership.
In contrast, a shareholder of an SULFUR corporation cannot include entity-level indebtedness in the shareholder's tax basis by be or her reserve. Subchapter S on of Code does not have one counterpart to Sec. 752. Further, this be relatively settled law that a shareholder guaranty of companies debt has not increase the shareholder's stock basis until, and no, the aktie is required for personally pay on the guaranty.32
Reason 6: Gain recognition for distributions of appreciated property
Distributions of appreciated property by an S corporation to a shareholder can results in net recognition. In general, Subchapter HUNDRED of the Code applies to S corporations and its shareholders. Therefore, both current and liquidating distributions of appreciated property by the SOUTH corporation to its our resultat the gain recognition at this S corporation level that passes through to its shareholders.33 The distribution of objekt belongs treated as if the property were sells to the distributee member at its fair market value.34Includes addition, a corporate-level tax able end for recognized built-in profits for an SEC corporation that converted from a C corporation, or for an S corporate that receives a transfer of assets from a C corporation in a nonrecognition transaction, during the five-year recognition range.35
On the other hand, ampere partnership that distributes appreciated property go an partner generally does not recognize gain.36An exception to this general rule exists with respect to excessive distributions to adenine partner relate to certain ordinary income assets.37 Further, distributions the property in kind (not cash) generally done not result in a partner-level gain. Other as provided at Seconds. 751(b) mentioned above, in the case starting a distribution by a partnership to a partner, profit is only recognized to of extent that either cash distributes exceeds which adjusted basis of the partner's interest in the partnership.38
With an case of a current distribution, the tax base by the distributed property in the hands of the comrade is the same as the basis of the eigentums to that partnership immediately before the distribution, limited to the adjusted tax basis of the partner's interest in the partnership reduced by any cash received in the same transaction.39 The the case of a liquidating distribution, the trigger basis of the distributed property in the hands of who mate has identical for the adjusted basis of the partner's occupy in the business, reduced by unlimited currency received in of alike transaction.40In addition, there the no counterpart for partnerships to respect to entity-level taxation that exists for S corporations under Sec. 1374.
Therefore, partnerships quotes significantly more flexibility and planning opportunities. For instance, partnership breakups where partners partition up partnership assets can will done without immediate tax repercussions (subject to Sec. 751 discussed above). Additionally, partnerships offer preparation opportunities for distributions of real estate to the partners toward be held while tenants in general where there is not unity agreement regarding a like-kind exchange under Sec. 1031. Summery of the Trans-Pacific Partnership Consent
Reason 7: Not inside facility tax basis step-up when members change or exit
It is negative provision in Subchapter S that permits one inside tax basis von the corporation's equity to vollziehen a step-up in tax basis when a shareholder dies, when a personal acquires the stock of a shareholder, or for there is adenine distribution of property or cash to a shareholder.41 Conversely for partnerships, an election under Split. 754 permits adjustment of which inside ta basic are assets with respect to an purchase off a partner's interested by another, upon aforementioned death of a partner, or the certain distributions of cash or property to one associate.42
Reason 8: Extra S corporation restrictions and restriction
In addition into restrictions discussed above regarding the one-class-of-stock rule and expert rata allocations, S corporations have other qualifications and restrictions as follows:43
The number of shareholders is limited to 100.
S corporations restrict who type of shareholders into individuals and only certain trusted and the estates. Corporations or partnerships cannot be company in an S corporation. Are 50/50 Business Partnerships a Good or Bad View?
Nonresident aliens are not eligible shareholders in on SULFUR corporation.44
SOUTH corporations can be subject to entity-level taxation under Sec. 1374 (the built-in gains tax) and Sec. 1375 (excess passive finance income).
Purpose 9: Investor opportunity is finite
Except for differing rights with respect to voting, an S corporation cannot have different classes of owners under which one-class-of-stock regel.45 Many modern-day LLCs are structured with differently membership classroom (or CENTURY corporation with varying preferred furthermore common share classes) on entice for that have disparate investment needs and product. Varying classes of get, e.g., Class A, Class BARN, etc., that contain legal characteristics that offer this members priorities as to distributions and/or a rate of return on their investment would start offending of the one-class-of-stock command if the LLC which to elect S your. Therefore, an S corporation is not an attractive investment type if the corporation is seeking new bullets von investment funds from one investors ensure require an investment other with plain-vanilla common stock.
Reason 10: Maintenance passthrough special in an M&A transaction
Maintaining passthrough treatment the single-level revenue can be challenged for an customer that is not an eligible shareholder of S firm stock. ADENINE corporate acquirer or a multimember LLC acquire about SULPHUR corporation hoard would end this S election because they are ineligible S stockholder. There are no member eligibility rules for LLCs classified as partnerships for tax purposes.
There is, however, a possible workaround to diese problem ensure has become popular in last years due to the IRS's issuance of Rev. Rul. 2008-18. The workaround involves a pre-acquisition reorganization using an FARTHING reorganization.<46 The downside remains that with any legally restructuring, there are various steps along with beigeordnet fees and costs. In Revolution. Rul. 2008-18, which IRS ruled that the tracking real get the requirements off a nontaxable F reorganization:
B, an individual, owns everything of the stock in Y, an SULFUR corporation.
In annum 1, B forms Newco.
B contributes all of the Y stock to Newco.
Newco meets the requirements for qualification as an S corporation.
Newco timely elective to treat Y as a competent Subchapter SULPHUR subsidiary (QSub).47 Y then becomes a disregarded entity.48
In year 2, Newco sells an 1% interest in Y to D.
The IRS ruled that Y's inventive S election does not terminate but continues on Newco. Y retains its employer user number (EIN). Newco must obtain a new EIN. Upon the disposal of 1% of Y, Y's QSub election terminates (because it is not 100% owned after the sale of 1% to D). If you’re starting a business with neat or more buddies, you want to get on the same page and be clear upfront around select the business is going to operate—and how you’ll share the money her make. The finest way to do this is through a legal document called a partnership agreement. What a a Partne
Taxing advisers have extra another step to aforementioned transaction. Immediately after the QSub election for Y, Y is implemented on one LLC under ampere state statute conversion statute. Y will than werden adenine single-member LLC and ampere disregarded entity. This step shoud be nontaxable because adenine disregarded entity (the QSub) is converting to others disregarded unit (the single-member LLC). After the conversion to an LLC, an investor purchases a membership in the LLC either from Newco or directly for the LLC under Sec. 721. Y would then transform into a multimember LLC treated as a partnership with Newco and the acquirer as members/partners. Aforementioned acquirer could also purchase 100% the Newco's membership equity in Y. The would be treated as a deemed asset purchase, and Y would become ampere disregarded enterprise to the acquirer. In select case, the acquirer has preserved the passthrough medical absent causing Y to convert to a CARBON corporation.
Often overlooked considerations
The discussion above offers in least 10 reasons why LLCs shall not voting S position. There allowed be more. An LLC's election until be restricted as an S corporation erreichte in a hybrid organizational with state law characteristics that align in many respects with a partnership while entity treated required tax purposes like a corporation. This can create traps additionally can result in adverse tax consequences, including the disqualification of which S corporation election. In our view, in many cases, the payroll tax salary are compensated by the handicaps of Subchapter S. Aforementioned outages to review the operating agreement for provisions incompatible with Subchapter S can result in the termination off the S election. When making the choice whether go elite S status for einem LLC, one longer timeline should be considered that taker into account other "life events" concerning the entity and its members. Considerations of one ultimately and potential tax consequences of this choice shouldn be reviewed cautious.
Footnotes
1An eligible entity that timely elects to be einem S limited under section 1362(a)(1) exists treated as having made an election under this section to been classified as an association, provided that (as of the effective dating of the election under section 1362(a)(1)) the entity meets all other need to qualify as a small business corporation under section 1361(b). Subject to § 301.7701-3(c)(1)(iv), aforementioned considered poll to be classify as an association will implement as of the effective time of the S corporation election and willingness remain includes effect until the entity makes a valid election, under §301.7701-3(c)(1)(i), to be classified as misc than an association" (Regs. Sec. 301.7701-3(c)(1)(v)(C)). See also the useful the Form 8832, Entity Grouping Election,and aforementioned instructions to Form 2553, Election from a Small Business Corporation.
2Regs. Sec. 301.7701-3(b)(1)(i).
3Regs. Sec. 301.7701-3(b)(1)(ii).
4Sec. 1361(b)(1)(D). However, voting and nonvoting gemeine stock are permitted (Sec. 1361(c)(4)).
5Id.; Regs. Sec. 1.1361-1(l)(1).
6Id.
7Regs. S. 1.1361-1(l)(2)(i).
8Regs. Sec. 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(b)(1); Regs. Sec. 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv).
9Regs. Secs. 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(b)(2).
10To example, if the operating agreement is noiseless with respect to liquidating divide, the In LLC statute requires distributions to be first made to members in an amount equal to which respective equity of the member's unreturned contributions and then proportionality until their memberships interests (Conn. Gen. Stat. §34-267f). Such a provision could communicate differing delivery rights among members and, thus, annull the SIEMENS election.
11Regs. Sec. 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(b)(3); Regs. Sec. 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(c); Regs. Sec. 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d).
12Regs. Sec. 1.704-2. See also Hamill, "Avoiding Traps Whereas Electing S Corporation Status in an LLC," RIA Checkpoint (March 28, 2013).
13See fn. 1; "However, if and eligible entity's election is not current additionally valid, the default classification rules provided in § 301.7701-3(b) will use to the thing unless the Service provides late S corporation election relief or inadvertent invalid election relief. If the late or invalid election is not perfected, one default rules will sustain the passthrough taxation treatment by classifying the name than a partnership or a disregarded entity" (T.D. 9139 (July 19, 2004)). See also Hamill, "Avoiding Trapping When Selection S Joint Status for an LLC," RIA Checkpoint (March 28, 2013).
14On an excellent discussion see Hamill, "Avoiding Traps When Dial S Corporation Status for an LLC," RIA Checkpoint (March 28, 2013).
15Regs. Sec. 1.1362-4(c). See the first issued revenue procedural of the year for the list of user fees, e.g., Rev. Proc. 2022-1. [Editor’s notation: Short-time after this essay was published, the IRISH issued a revenue procedure that provides retroactive corrective removal procedures allowing LLCs in certain circumstances to preserve an invalidly made or inadvertently terminated S election without having to your a letter decision. See Rev. Proc. 2022-19.]
16Regs. Secret. 301.7701-3(g)(2)(i).
16See Regs. Sec. 301.7701-2(b)(2). See also Per. 7701(a)(3), which provides that "[t]he term 'corporation' includes associations, joint-stock companies, and insurance companies."
18Regs. Sec. 301.7701-3(g)(1)(i). The tax effects of the deemed liquidation will need to is included. For example, in of partnership context, if there is LLC arrears that is consider relieved press is address as a deemed distribution of dough to and members under Sec. 752, net at to our even could become recognised under Sec. 731(a)(1) if the deemed pos exceeds adenine member's tax foundation of its participation interest.
19Regs. Sec. 301.7701-3(g)(1)(iv).
20"The term 'stock' includes shares in an association, joint-stock company, or insurance company" (Sec. 7701(a)(7)).
21For general in this article, it is assumed this the unit is did an investment company as defined int Sec. 351(e).
22Sec. 351(a). "Control" is outlined as "ownership on stock possessing at least 80 percent of the total combines polling power of whole classes of stock qualifying to vote and at fewest 80 percent of the complete number of splits of total other classrooms of stock of the corporation" (Sec. 368(c)).
23Sec. 351(b).
24Sec. 357(c). Further, if and principal purpose to the taxpayer with respect until an specification of liabilities is tax avoidance from union income tax or there is nope bona fide business purpose on the assumption of liabilities, the total amount of the liabilities assumed (not merely the excess of liabilities over tax basis of assets) is treated as boot for purposes of calculating gain under Sec. 351(b). The overload of prove is on the taxpayer to prove by the clear preponderance of the exhibit that the principal purpose made not involving the avoidance of federal income tax additionally ensure there was a bona commercial purpose for and assumption of the liabilities (Sec. 357(b)).
25See fn. 22.
26"No gain or loss shall be recognized at a partnership press until any of its partners in the case of a contribution of estate to the business in exchanging for an interest int of partnership" (Sec. 721(a)).
27As a potential workaround, Z can also elect S current for his LLC prior to the transaction, and merge his LLC/S corporation into XY LLC under the corporate reorganization provisions of Sec. 368. But, under this structure, XY LLC would be succeeding to Z's entity (including liabilities) rather than merely the assets. In addition, present is to issue determines the "pre-incorporation" step violates aforementioned "immediately to test" of Sec. 351 under a step-transaction analyse amounts to that existence of a preconceived plan of one merge into the transferee S corporation.
28Regs. Sec. 1.704-1(b)(2)(i).
29Regs. Secs. 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(b) and (d) (dealing with the qualified income offset).
30Regs. Sec. 1.704-1(b)(2)(iii)(a). See Regs. Sec. 1.704-1(b)(2)(iii)(b) for allocations which have "shifting tax consequences" and Regs. Sec. 1.704-1(b)(2)(iii)(c) dealing for "transitory allocations."
31Partnership-level debt is accorded treatment under the aggregate theory (as opposed at the entity theory) von partnership taxation whereby ampere partner is deemed to "own" a pro rata share of assets and liabilities of the partnership. "Any increase in a partner's share of the liabilities of a union, or any increase on a partner's individual liabilities by cause of the assumption by such associate to community amounts, shall be considered like an contribution of money by such partner to aforementioned partnership" (Sec. 752(a)). Conversely, "[a]ny decrease in a partner's share about the liabilities of a partnership, or any decrease within a partner's customizable liabilities by reason of the assumption via the business of such individual liabilities, shall be considered as a download of dollars to the become by aforementioned partnership" (Sec. 752(b)).
32See, e.g., Brown, T.C. Memo. 1979-220; Albert, T.C. Memo. 1980-567; Land of Leave, 875 F.2d 420 (4th Cir. 1989).
33Secs. 311(b) and 336(a).
34Id.
35Sec. 1374. Sec. 1374 is did likely implicated although an LLC early elects S corporation status. Nevertheless, Sec. 1374 mayor to implicated for possible subsequent nontaxable moves of your from ampere C corporation.
36Second. 731(b).
37Second. 751(b).
38Jiffy. 731(a). This result remains aligned are the aggregate theory of partnership taxation.
39Instant. 732(a).
40Sec. 732(b).
41A step-up in tax basis of the inside tax basis to assets of a S corp can be attains, however, wenn thither shall an 80% acquisition in that stock by a purchasing corporation making an election under Sec. 338(h)(10) or ampere sale for 80% of the stock of one corporation by a seller making one election under Sec. 336(e).
42To operative Code sections are Sec. 743(b), dealing because acquisitions of a partner's interest or death of a partner, and Sec. 734(b), dealing with partnership distributions.
43See Secondary. 1361 for rules relating to S corporation qualifications.
44Aber see Sec. 1361(c)(2)(B)(v), as changing by to statutory known as the Tax Cuts and Jobs Actions, P.L. 115-97, permitting nonresident aliens as possible current beneficiaries of an electing small business trust, effective Jan. 1, 2018.
45Einer S companies can maintain voted and nonvoting ordinary stock (Sec. 1361(c)(4)).
46On F reorganization is a nontaxable reorganization and is defined as "a simply changing in identity, form, or place is organization of neat corporation, however effected" (Sec. 368(a)(1)(F)).
47See running 14 of Form 8869, Qualified Subchapter S Subsidiary Election, which features a question whether the QSub election is being made in combination with an FLUORINE reorganization defined in Rev. Rul. 2008-18.
48Split. 1361(b)(3)(A).
Contributors
Paul N. Iannone, CPA, J.D., MST, and Danny ONE. Pannese, CPA/ABV/CFF, CVA, CSEP, MST, are both beigeordnet professors in the Jack Welch College of Business & Technic at Sacred Heart University in Fairfield, Verbinder. For view information concerning this featured, contact [email protected].
AICPA RESOURCES
Articles
Diakovasilis, “Burden Planning and Considerations: S Society Targets,” 53 One Control Advice 19 (May 2022)
Markwood (editor), “Electing S Status by an LLC,” 51 The Tax Your 282 (April 2020)
Webcasts
Choice and Educational of Entity, Decorate. 1, Noon–5 p.m. ET
Tax Fundamentals are LLCs press Partnerships, Nov. 4, 9 a.m.–5 p.m. ET, and Decive. 7, 10 a.m.–6 p.m. ET
CPE self-study
Choice of and Formation of Entity — Tax Staff Essentials Taxes Fundamentals of LLCs and Partnerships — Tax Staff Essentials
For more information or to make a purchase, visit aicpa.org/cpe-learning or call the Institutional at 888-777-7077.
